MIFTAH
Friday, 19 April. 2024
 
Your Key to Palestine
The Palestinian Initiatives for The Promotoion of Global Dialogue and Democracy
 
 
 

A Turkish initiative to build an Israeli-Palestinian medical compound on the Israeli side of the Jalameh crossing won the blessing of the Turkish military as well as the support of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, President Shimon Peres and Defense Minister Ehud Barak. The Israeli defense establishment, evidently the final arbiter in such matters, is to blame for the project's premature demise, although final responsibility for the decision lies with the prime minister and defense minister.

The project's impending cancellation has added fuel to the nasty fire that recently erupted between the Jewish state and the important Muslim state, relations which were already screeching to a halt, and it is impeding the prospects for significant positive progress between Israel and the Palestinians. On a more prosaic level, it also blocks an opportunity for a new hospital to be built in Israel, with Turkish funding.

It all began two years ago, during a visit by Olmert to Ankara. His Turkish counterpart, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, asked his guest to meet with his friend, Prof. Ali Dogramaci, rector of Bilkent University in Ankara and a member of one of Turkey's wealthiest and most important families. Dogramaci's father, Prof. Ihsan Dogramaci, 94, twice turned down proffered appointments as president of Turkey.

Ali Dogramaci told Olmert about his plan to build a "Peace Campus" - a medical compound on the Israeli side of the Jalameh crossing, a checkpoint on the Green Line, with an investment of $850 million (approximately NIS 3.5 billion). The plan called for a 200-bed children's hospital, an outpatient clinic staffed by specialists, and a hotel to accommodate the families of Palestinian patients. The patients would be cared for by Israeli, Palestinian and foreign doctors, nurses and auxiliary staff. Employees would live in buildings within the compound, which would also encompass schools, a shopping and entertainment complex and a sports center.

Dogramaci asked Olmert for two things: an allocation of 500 dunams (125 acres) for the project, and creation of a designated gateway to facilitate the quick passage of a small group of staff who would work in the admissions office on the Palestinian side. He agreed that all patients and staff from the Palestinian side would have to obtain entry permits from Israel. He also pledged to finance the compound's operation for 20 years, and to comply with all security-related requests concerning entrance into the compound. Inspections would continue to be carried out at the Jalameh crossing. At the end of this period, Dogramaci promised, he would transfer the compound completely to the State of Israel, which could then do with it as it saw fit. He further pledged that if the project went well, he would build a similar compound on the Palestinian side.

Peres, Barak, Netanyahu

Upon his return to Israel, Olmert entrusted the project to Shimon Peres, then the minister for development of the Negev and the Galilee, who in turn appointed Brig. Gen. (res.) Ilan Paz, former head of the Civil Administration in the West Bank, as Israel's liaison to Dogramaci on the project. Peres continued to take an interest in the project after he became president. He invited Dogramaci to his new office to show his support and also urged Barak to hold a meeting with him.

In February of last year, when Barak visited Ankara, Dogramaci asked his father to invite the Israeli defense minister to a formal dinner at his home, at which Barak was seated next to Turkish President Abdullah Gul. Barak gave the project his blessing and promised that his door would always be open to Dogramaci and his people.

Dogramaci also met with Vice Premier Haim Ramon, Interior Minister Meir Sheetrit, Housing Minister Ze'ev Boim, Infrastructure Minister Benjamin Eliezer and Jacob Edery, the new minister of development of the Negev and the Galilee, and sources close to the project say he received expressions of approval from all of them. Dogramaci didn't stop there; he also met twice with opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu. In November 2007, Netanyahu gave him a letter in which he expressed his support in principle for the project. Netanyahu told Haaretz: "I liked the plan because it fit in with my view regarding economic and humanitarian cooperation with the Palestinians." He pledged that if he became prime minister, he would remove any obstacles to the compound's development.

Turkey's ambassador to Israel, Namik Tan, attended all the meetings and relayed the message that the highest echelons of the Turkish government, including Prime Minister Erdogan, stood behind the project and were prepared to take part in its financing and to provide guarantees for its construction.

Danny Atar, chairman of the Gilboa regional council, envisioned the hotels that would be built around the compound and would provide an income to area residents who'd been hit hard by unemployment. He says the project had the potential to employ hundreds. He began speaking with the directors of local hospitals about medical and research cooperation with the future institution.

Atar hosted Dogramaci in his office, and he introduced him to his friend, Jenin governor Kadura Musa. For years, the two of them had been dreaming of this type of joint enterprise. Atar found a 500-dunam parcel of land for the purpose, and Musa, who has transformed Jenin from a city of suicide bombers into a town with hardly any violence, pledged not to let anyone interfere with the special project.

The defense establishment - the Shin Bet, IDF and the NSC - was asked to approve the project, and that's when questions began to arise. People associated with the project say the message from them was: Why should we look for trouble? What will happen if Hamas takes control of the West Bank? And what will we do if a terrorist infiltrates the compound and kidnaps a doctor?

An $850-million peace initiative and gift will go down the drain? That's not our problem, said senior defense officials. If the donor is so concerned about Palestinian children, let him build them a hospital in Jenin. The Turks will be offended? The Foreign Ministry will deal with that. The prime minister and defense minister gave the project their blessing? Tomorrow they'll be out of office and we're the ones who will be left with the headache.

In June 2008, Defense Ministry director general Pinchas Buchris invited Ilan Paz and representatives from the IDF, the Shin Bet security service, the National Security Council and the checkpoint administration to his office to discuss all the aspects of the project. Paz said at the meeting that the developer had pledged to finance all the security expenses, including the cost of crossing-point inspections, under the direction and supervision of Israeli security officials. After listening patiently to the project's opponents, Buchris said he felt that they hadn't taken the trouble to study the plan with enough care. He said he was leaving the decision to Barak, the minister, but asked the various officials to do their homework, meet with Paz again and come back to him with their comments.

Buchris did not respond when contacted by Haaretz. Paz is still waiting for a phone call from the relevant officials. Six months ago, the Ministry for the Development of the Negev and the Galilee told him it no longer needed his services, and since then he has been serving as Dogramaci's liaison on a volunteer basis, in an attempt to rescue the project and keep it alive.

Make up your minds

In early December, almost two years after the first meeting between Olmert and the developer, Paz sent a letter to the Prime Minister's Bureau with copies to the president and all the ministers who'd heaped their praises on Dogramaci. He asked Olmert to make a government decision with regard to the project. If the government wished to see the medical compound become a reality, it should task the Defense Ministry or the Infrastructure Ministry with advancing the plan. If the government was not interested in the project, he asked for it to so kind as to inform the developer and the Turkish government of Israel's intention to decline the offer.

The answer arrived four weeks later. An aide to the director general of the Prime Minister's Office informed Paz that due to "a lack of security feasibility," the project was not approved. This was at the height of Operation Cast Lead, which sparked a severe crisis in Israel-Turkey relations. Dogramaci continued to believe, however, that the Israeli side would keep its promises.

After repeated requests for comment, Paz offered this reply: "It's too bad that after so many of the country's leaders welcomed the project, they're letting the defense establishment sabotage it. I certainly don't belittle security considerations, but the time has come to stop viewing everything through the hole of the gun-sight and to understand that a political-security reality is not built solely by means of targeted assassinations and checkpoints. Anyone who claims that the compound will constitute a security hazard hasn't bothered to read the plan."

Namik Tan, the Turkish ambassador to Israel, confirmed that all the politicians who met with Dogramaci praised the project, but said that unfortunately, "for practical reasons," it did not take further shape, so that now all he can do is hope that the new government will approve it. He said he also hoped that the political echelon would take advantage of the opportunity to also instruct the security echelon to remove the obstacles standing in the way of plans to build industrial zones in Tarkumiya and Jalama, on Palestinian land.

Tan says that his government invited experts and officials from Israel to Turkey so they could see similar projects built by Dogramaci that have been a great success. "My government, including the most senior echelon, considers the Peace Campus in Gilboa to be a most important project. The entire Turkish establishment wholeheartedly supports it," says the ambassador.

A spokesperson for the Foreign Ministry told Haaretz that the project raises tricky security issues that require thorough examination. The defense minister's office and the Shin Bet declined to provide a response. The IDF Spokesman said that the army supports the construction of the project and assistance to the Palestinians, on condition that it be built in Palestinian territory.

More reliable than Palestinians

The idea of building the project in Palestinian territory was presented to Dogramaci, but he insists that the compound be built on the Israeli side, because he finds Israel more reliable than the Palestinians. He also attributes importance to Israel being able to present the project as a gesture of reconciliation and peace. He is still waiting for an official response from Israel; if it turns down the project, he says he will seek to build it somewhere else.

Danny Atar is from the mainstream of the Labor Party, and was among the first to press the political echelon to build the separation fence. Still, he believes that such barriers alone are not a long-term answer. "For years, every time terror increased, we told the Palestinians that as long as we have no quiet, they would pay the price. Now, in the past year, thanks to a courageous and wise governor, Jenin has become the quietest place in the territories. Governor Kadura Musa's message to his population has been that economic well-being and health services go hand-in-hand with law and order. If we kill the Turkish peace compound, we'll be showing them that he was mistaken."

Atar emphasizes that Dogramaci asked him for nothing at all except for a suitable piece of land near the seam line. As for the security officials' arguments, he says: "As a former military man, I say with full confidence that there is no security problem here. This is just an invented excuse and everyone can see that. It's a policy of fear befitting unenlightened regimes."

 
 
Read More...
 
 
By the Same Author
 
Footer
Contact us
Rimawi Bldg, 3rd floor
14 Emil Touma Street,
Al Massayef, Ramallah
Postalcode P6058131

Mailing address:
P.O.Box 69647
Jerusalem
 
 
Palestine
972-2-298 9490/1
972-2-298 9492
info@miftah.org

 
All Rights Reserved © Copyright,MIFTAH 2023
Subscribe to MIFTAH's mailing list
* indicates required